RFC-X: Review X#

or

RFC-X: Comment X#

Replace the title above of this file with “RFC-NUM: Review NUM”. Update the tag to (rfcs:rfcNUM:reviewNUM) and remove the (rfc1-review-template) tag. Add your names and affiliations to the authors section above (and optionally ORCID and GitHub username) as well as the date of submission and your recommendation (accept, major_changes, minor_changes, reject).

For a Comment, the recommendation field may be left blank. Please also change the mentions of “review” to “comment” where appropriate, including the MyST target anchor, and the title of the file.

The document-authors directive will automatically pull the information from the YAML front matter and display it in a table.

The fields are described by the LinkML schema in rfc/schema/front_matter.yaml, which is what CI checks every review, comment and response against. To check yours yourself, run pip install linkml and then python rfc/schema/validate.py from the root of the repository.

Authors#

Author 11 ORCID GitHub and Author 22 ORCID GitHub

1 Affiliation X

2 Affiliation Y

Conflicts of interest (optional)#

This section should be included if authors feel that there is any background information (shared grants, financial interests, etc.) which should be shared with the community for transparency. This will not prevent the Review Authors from submitting a review, but may trigger the addition of other Reviewers.

Summary#

Significant comments and questions#

Subheadings#

Structure any subheadings as necessary.

Minor comments and questions#

Similarly, add any subheadings necessary

Recommendation#

Adopt, major changes, minor changes, reject (as last resort)

See the list of recommendations under “RFC” in RFC-1.